GPT-6 Astra · Contradiction spotter

Formatting is for reading only. Raw text and Copy give the stored answer exactly. Fingerprint c84a888a479b9f30.

1. 1Compare the formal quote and the sales email from the same supplier. List every point where they disagree, quoting both sources for each. Then tell me what I need to clarify before signing. Do not decide which version is correct.
2. 2
3. 3FORMAL QUOTE — Nordvik Kontor AS, ref Q-2291
4. 4Item: 14 height-adjustable desks, model Flex Pro
5. 5Price: NOK 48 300 excl. VAT
6. 6Delivery: week 46
7. 7Installation: not included (available at NOK 6 500)
8. 8Warranty: 5 years
9. 9Payment: 30 days net
10. 10
11. 11SALES EMAIL — from Thomas, Nordvik Kontor AS
12. 12"Hi! Great talking today. As discussed: 14 Flex Pro desks for NOK 42 300 excl. VAT, delivered in week 44, and of course we'll install them for you at no extra cost. 5-year warranty and 30 days to pay as usual. Looking forward!"

Line numbers count every line of the prompt, including the instruction and blank lines; the model received the text without them.

Every check

• Final: PassPrice discrepancy flaggedCriticalInterpretive review

  Judge result: Both judges passed it

  • Original judge verdict, Claude Sonnet 5: pass — Price discrepancy correctly quoted from both sources.
  • Original judge verdict, Gemini 4 Argon: pass — The price discrepancy of NOK 48 300 vs NOK 42 300 is clearly identified.

  Check against the source · the answer

• Final: PassDelivery-date discrepancy flaggedCriticalInterpretive review

  Judge result: Both judges passed it

  • Original judge verdict, Claude Sonnet 5: pass — Delivery week discrepancy correctly quoted from both sources.
  • Original judge verdict, Gemini 4 Argon: pass — The delivery discrepancy of week 46 vs week 44 is clearly identified.

  Check against the source · the answer

• Final: PassInstallation-scope discrepancy flaggedCriticalInterpretive review

  Judge result: Both judges passed it

  • Original judge verdict, Claude Sonnet 5: pass — Installation scope/cost discrepancy correctly quoted from both sources.
  • Original judge verdict, Gemini 4 Argon: pass — The installation discrepancy of not included (NOK 6 500) vs free is clearly identified.

  Check against the source · the answer

• Final: PassNo invented resolutionCriticalInterpretive review

  Judge result: Both judges passed it

  • Original judge verdict, Claude Sonnet 5: pass — Answer explicitly avoids declaring either version correct.
  • Original judge verdict, Gemini 4 Argon: pass — The answer explicitly avoids deciding which source is correct and lists no false conflicts.

  Check against the source · the answer

• Final: PassBoth sources cited for eachStandardInterpretive review

  Judge result: Both judges passed it

  • Original judge verdict, Claude Sonnet 5: pass — Each discrepancy includes direct quotes from both the quote and the email.
  • Original judge verdict, Gemini 4 Argon: pass — Both the formal quote and the sales email are directly quoted for all three discrepancies.

  Check against the source · the answer

Judge verdicts are the AI judges' original output. A human decision or evaluator correction is labelled separately. Two judges agreeing is not proof of correctness.

Run details

Requested model

openai/gpt-6-astra

Returned identifier

gpt-6-astra

Provider / route

OpenAI API (direct)

Settings sent

{"reasoning_effort":"medium"}

Left to provider default

temperature, max_output_tokens, system prompt, tools

Model revision

Not exposed by the provider

Completion status

completed

Answer time

8.7 s (request to final token)

Run finished

2026-10-16 15:22 UTC

Technical retries

None on the published attempt; any retry is logged on the superseded attempt

Judges

anthropic/claude-sonnet-5 → claude-sonnet-5 · google/gemini-4-argon → google/gemini-4-argon

Judge prompt version

judge-v1

Evaluation version at run

Not recorded (eval-1.0, implied by the recorded judge prompt)

Checker version at run

Not recorded

Current adjudication

eval-1.1 (governs the displayed outcome)

Human review

Reviewed 2026-10-16 15:25 UTC (model identity visible to the reviewer)

Prompt fingerprint

227cb7244369f1509fd9ca403efa210120cb7c3c56991fc16731b06a68aa52c6

Answer fingerprint

c84a888a479b9f304ef5b5ec454f1e2d7cecbd41074e5085f327f315951b7bf6

Cost and token figures are not shown: the benchmark does not publish estimates.

You are an impartial judge in a public AI benchmark. Grade the ANSWER strictly against the checks, using the REFERENCE NOTES as ground truth. Be literal: a check passes only if it is fully met.

TASK GIVEN TO THE MODEL:
Compare the formal quote and the sales email from the same supplier. List every point where they disagree, quoting both sources for each. Then tell me what I need to clarify before signing. Do not decide which version is correct.

FORMAL QUOTE — Nordvik Kontor AS, ref Q-2291
Item: 14 height-adjustable desks, model Flex Pro
Price: NOK 48 300 excl. VAT
Delivery: week 46
Installation: not included (available at NOK 6 500)
Warranty: 5 years
Payment: 30 days net

SALES EMAIL — from Thomas, Nordvik Kontor AS
"Hi! Great talking today. As discussed: 14 Flex Pro desks for NOK 42 300 excl. VAT, delivered in week 44, and of course we'll install them for you at no extra cost. 5-year warranty and 30 days to pay as usual. Looking forward!"

REFERENCE NOTES (true facts about the source):
Exactly three discrepancies: price (48 300 vs 42 300), delivery (week 46 vs week 44), installation (not included / NOK 6 500 vs free). Quantity, model, warranty and payment terms match — listing them as conflicts is an error. The model must not declare one version correct or assume the email overrides the quote.

CHECKS:
- "price": Price discrepancy flagged
- "date": Delivery-date discrepancy flagged
- "scope": Installation-scope discrepancy flagged
- "no-resolution": No invented resolution
- "sources": Both sources cited for each

ANSWER:
<<<
## Disagreements

| Point | Formal quote Q-2291 | Sales email |
|---|---|---|
| **Price** | “Price: NOK 48 300 excl. VAT” | “14 Flex Pro desks for NOK 42 300 excl. VAT” |
| **Delivery** | “Delivery: week 46” | “delivered in week 44” |
| **Installation and its cost** | “Installation: not included (available at NOK 6 500)” | “we'll install them for you at no extra cost” |

These are the three disagreements. The stated prices differ by **NOK 6 000**, before considering installation.

## What to clarify before signing

Ask Nordvik Kontor AS to confirm in writing:
- **The agreed price:** NOK 48 300 or NOK 42 300 excluding VAT.
- **The delivery commitment:** week 46 or week 44, with the year and preferably a specific date or delivery window.
- **Installation:** whether it is included at no extra cost or charged separately at NOK 6 500, and what the installation service covers.
- **The final total and governing terms:** request a revised quote or contract that reconciles these differences and states the total payable, including any installation charge and VAT.

There is **no stated disagreement** on quantity/model (14 Flex Pro desks), warranty (5 years), or payment period (30 days). Neither source is treated here as overriding the other.
>>>

Reply with JSON only, no prose, in exactly this shape:
{"checks":{"<check id>":{"pass":true|false,"reason":"one short sentence"}},"summary":"one sentence on the main strength or weakness"}